Xhaka Feels Alonso’s Tactical Flexibility Make Him Chelsea’s Smarter Long-Term Bet Than Arteta?
Xhaka’s verdict hands Arsenal a sharp tactical comparison between their boss and Chelsea’s new man
Granit Xhaka’s past insight on Mikel Arteta and Xabi Alonso has taken on fresh relevance for both Arsenal and Chelsea. Having played under both managers, the Swiss midfielder told the Professional Footballers’ Association in 2024 that Alonso shows greater tactical flexibility than his former Arsenal boss. With Alonso now confirmed as Chelsea’s permanent head coach on a four-year deal starting 1 July 2026, his adaptable approach will bring a direct contrast to Arteta’s more rigid 4-3-3 structure.
What does Xhaka actually say about the two managers?
Speaking to the PFA, Xhaka explained that Arteta works with a strict, unwavering philosophy. He relies on a back four, a 4-3-3 shape, one holding midfielder, and two eights, rarely shifting from that system regardless of the opponent. Alonso, on the other hand, fluidly moves between a back four and a back five, preferring two number sixes holding their positions rather than pressing freely up the pitch.
Xhaka stressed that both approaches work because every top coach needs a clear identity, but noted that Alonso’s willingness to change shapes gives him a wider tactical vocabulary. Chelsea’s new manager arrives after leaving Real Madrid, making this Stamford Bridge appointment his first senior role since that exit.
Chelsea board has given a massive power to Xabi Alonso
What does this tactical gap mean for Arsenal going forward?
Arteta‘s rigid system remains both his greatest strength and his most obvious limitation. While his structured pressing and positional discipline turned Arsenal into genuine title contenders, opponents who figure out the shape early and sit deep have often exposed the lack of a convincing Plan B.
Alonso at Chelsea, with the freedom to switch between a back four and a back five mid-match, could hand Arteta a much tougher tactical puzzle than he is used to facing in the Premier League. Chelsea’s 2026/27 squad has real depth, and if Alonso uses two disciplined sixes just as Xhaka described, the Blues could suffocate Arsenal’s transition play much better than they have in recent meetings.
3 Players Xabi Alonso should sign as new Chelsea manager
For Arsenal fans, that is the most uncomfortable takeaway here, not just that Chelsea secured a top manager, but that he might have the exact tactical answers Arteta has spent years trying to find. Arteta’s system is brilliant; Alonso’s simply has more variety.
